Introduction

Main critique theme

Critique theme is focused and clearly explained

Significance

Makes clear what motivates them to explore main theme/question and significance

Background

Explains background on the problem

Body content and article evaluation

Overall

each section of body content provides details of all 3 articles, articles are thoroughly but concisely compared, contrasted and evaluated clearly

Introduce articles

Give article details (citation), provide each paper's objective/hypotheses

Article methods

Methods summarized and evaluated completely for all 3 articles

Article results

Results are summarized and evaluated, tables/figures used from papers to help with critique

Article discussions

Discussions are summarized and thoroughly evaluated for all 3 articles

Summary

Summarizes strengths and weaknesses of each article, makes a concluding statement overall about the critique theme

Speculation

Suggests what should be done next, points out new questions raised by work

Citation slide

Any studies mentioned during the presentation are listed and all publication information given in a 'References' slide

Organization of presentation

Purpose of slides

Purpose of each slide is clear to the listener (title of slide contains premise)

Continuity

Effective transitions between slides contribute to a continuous sequence of connected ideas, slides flow well

Roadmap

Provides a roadmap/preview then several reminders/singpost during the talk so that the listener never feels lost

Figures

Every figure and image is clearly labeled and all figures are fully explained by the presenter

Attractiveness

slides are laid out well, text is easy to read and colors do not clash, there are no distracting transitions

Timing

15 min